patching...
Update: For more local news about the community, follow Fox Point-Bayside Patch on Facebook »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Opinion: Too Much Homework Leaves No Time to Be A Kid

Bayside sixth-grader completes his own study on why students have so much homework and the negative impacts of such a heavy load.

 

Student: “Why do teachers give out homework?”

Teacher: “Well, that is obvious: to try to prepare you for your future.”

Student: “But, why do teachers give out so much homework?”

Teacher:  “Well, that is because of the, um…  We need to… in order to…  Ah, we need to simply, ah, challenge you, um, in order to make you a better student.”

In order for teachers to prepare us for our future, we have homework nightly. But, why we have so much of this homework is a totally different matter, for which the answer: “We need to challenge you more,” is not an acceptable answer from a teacher.

As sixth-graders, we are simply children; we are not even teenagers. And yet, we sometimes sit at our desks until 11 p.m. to finish the often enormous amounts of homework that we received only hours earlier.

What I hope to persuade you into recognizing is what this amount of work does to us, not only mentally, but also physically, and that teachers ultimately reduce the amount of work they assign every night.

I am not only speaking for me, or the entire sixth grade, but for the hundreds and thousands of Wisconsin kids that also struggle with the intense physical and mental labor of the amount of homework that we receive at such an early age.

First and foremost, one reason why teachers should give out less homework is because homework, itself, is environmentally damaging to our planet. Homework uses paper, paper comes from trees, and trees are used for oxygen. Lower amounts of oxygen leads to less life on Earth; so, in other words, homework kills our planet. Every year, 61.5 million trees are killed and used for paper. And that same paper is used for children’s homework. That is essentially cutting down 61.5 million sources of oxygen every year. Unnecessary extra amounts of school work that we do at our houses are not worth the toll it takes on our Earth.

Consider, too, that kids have lives beyond school and schoolwork. About 65 percent of kids, ages of 6-13, play competitive sports. But, unfortunately, some of those kids quit playing the sport they love due to the fact that they have too much schoolwork to tackle during their evening.

If a kid has three baseball practices a week, which consumes 2.5 hours of his Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday afternoons, how do you think he or she feels? He or she would obviously feel very tired, right? But, now imagine if that same kid had two hours of homework three of the five days that he or she has school. He or she would feel exhausted, stressed, and maybe depressed after weeks of this. Now, too much of this school work, along with hours of sports activities, can start to consume a child’s late afternoons, weekends, and even nights. Pursuing this further, now the same kid is having trouble with homework, feeling stressed with the amount given, and is not having the time to be a kid anymore. He or she now feels that the real problem is the sport(s) activity that is consuming an extra amount of work time, of which he or she could use to do his schoolwork. So, the kid begins to hate his or her school and school work, along with his or her sports activities. In the end, kids sometimes either quit the sports activities that they are doing, or even extra-curricular activities that he/she does at school. Or, in turn, they suffer through it.

An example of this would be Michael. As an advanced fifth-grade student, he pushes himself, but due to the amount of homework he had at the end of the school year last year, he had to quit tennis. Was this really Michael’s fault? No.

Too much homework means kids are sleeping less than they should. Studies show that children need an average of 10 hours of sleep each night. But, lots of schoolwork along with sports and extra-circular activities mean kids work late into the night to finish their work, affecting them mentally and physically. Mental effects due to lack of sleep can be: irritability, memory loss, and drowsiness. Continued sleep deprivation can result in trouble concentrating, blurry vision, impaired judgment, and even more severe mental effects. Physical effects can also be memory loss, aching muscles, and something that no parent wants to see their child go through: depression.  So, it is very important that we get the right amount of sleep we need by reducing the amount of homework, so…well…we can stay healthy.

Researchers at Duke University support the ten minute rule. This is where each grade level gets 10 minutes of homework per day per grade level (20 minutes for second grade, 40 minutes for fourth, 60 minutes for sixth, etc.).

Finally, one more reason why teachers should give out less homework is that they are are unaware of the havoc in the home that too much homework creates.  Over 43 percent of children’s parents do their homework for them, and over 85 percent help them with, if not do parts of their homework!

Lastly, my final examples of how more homework is more counterproductive than productive is that students like me, along with parents, are beginning to notice this matter throughout the United States, and are becoming more concerned and worried for their children. More and more kids each day are starting to notice how unnecessary and stressful this extra work is on their selves, and they are starting to find school a chore rather than an enjoyment and a place to learn. What disturbs me most though about this problem is that it all relates back to one problem, and we still do not fix it. So, what do we do to solve these three problems, we go to the source.

In conclusion, struggling schoolmanship, sleeping problems, quitting sports and extra-curricular activities, health problems, kids not turning in their homework, worried parents, angry parents, stressed-out children, all relate to one single thing that teachers and teaching staffs around the United States have failed to notice and failed to take action on: There is too much homework. Will you take action and stand up for what is right?

Related Topics: Bayside Middle School, Homework, Lance Falk, and Susie Falk

Patch_comments_icon

Sarah Worthman

1:26 pm on Friday, April 6, 2012

What do you think: Are kids given too much homework? Not enough?

Reply
Comment_arrow

CatMM

8:27 am on Saturday, April 7, 2012

I agree with Lance. Two hours of homework a night seems very excessive. How many adults bring home two hours of work a night? Children should be able to participate in sports and other healthy activities, have family time, and still get the amound of sleep they need each night. The ten minute rule makes good sense to me. By the way, I think this is a very well written, thought out article. I can tell Lance has been doing his homework! :)

Jennifer Wiegers

8:13 pm on Friday, April 6, 2012

I absolutely agree with Lance - homework is too dominant and there needs to be a better balance!

Reply

Fran Diggs

8:04 am on Saturday, April 7, 2012

There needs to be a distinction between busy work and homework. I would say some teachers need to reduce some of the busy work. But that said, this is about managing time and sucking it up. Kids and parents complaining about too much homework are the same parents who drag their kids out after school for dinners and practices and when they get home at 7p with a tired kid who spends half the time complaining about 2 hours of homework. Instead, you could have skipped that precious basketball practice and mcd's drive thru and been home eating while starting homework at 4p. All of my 3 kids play sports at NHS and are good students. They take part in several activities in and out of school. And my husband and I both work full time. But school always came first, and we helped them in middle school to figure out how to manage their time, prioritize and GTD! Not how to complain and write notes to the teacher about how lazy they are.

Reply
Comment_arrow

CowDung

11:35 am on Wednesday, April 11, 2012

I think that you have a very good point with your 'busy work/homework' distinction. In addition to the 'busy work', it seems that a lot of the homework is much more involved than it needs to be. The efforts to address everyone's learning style seems to be the culprit.

Instead of just doing a bunch of math problems, their math homework consists of doing math problems using different methods of solving, finding and cutting out pictures in magazines, writing sentences/paragraphs, drawing and coloring pictures, etc.

The result is that math homework takes much longer than it really should to reinforce a given concept.

Comment_arrow

Elwood

11:48 pm on Tuesday, March 12, 2013

You have extraordinary kids who will each likely be the Valedictorian of their class and then go on to Harvard, Yale or even NYU. My kids are smart effective and we don't take them to MC'ds after school in fact my 7th grader will say Dad I have a lot of homework and need to get right home. Will she better for it down the road, yeah probably so, but I feel terrible that she can't just relax more after school. By the time the weekend gets here she is wiped out and would rather rest than go out. I used to tell my kids you have it made right now when they were in grade school. I can honestly say their day is much tougher than mine and that’s not easy! I am extremely proud of my kids, I have learned much from them.

Lance J. Falk

10:11 am on Saturday, April 7, 2012

Well, miss, maybe you should have done your homework because being lazy has absolutely no part of this. I am not speaking of that small percentage of children who are too lazy to do their work and shrug it off, I am talking about the children that really put in the effort, but are tied up with work, sports, and extra-curricular activities. I understand your point about sucking it up (of which you could have used a more thoughtful term like "budgeting your time"), and that you sometimes need to skip your sports activity. But, this is not becoming just "skipping that one precious sports acitivty", but literally quitting or skipping many practices of a sport to finish the large amounts of schoolwork. But, though, there are those kids whose lives are homework, but, then again, there are those kids who budget their time, but feel completely overworked. I understand your point, but something will need to give, and children's health and afterschool lives should not be it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Absolutelyfabulous

12:52 pm on Saturday, April 7, 2012

How much of this article/reply has been w/ the assistance of Mr. Falk's parents?

Misty J.

10:36 am on Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Lance,
I can't help but compliment your well-organized persuasive article. You have a catchy beginning, details that are thoroughly explained, transitions that connect your ideas, and a solid conclusion. You put your heart in to the article and included personal examples and referenced research. Well done! You should thank your teachers, past and present, for preparing to express your opinions in this public format. Best of luck to you Lance!

Reply

CLD

4:46 pm on Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Lance,
I understand your frustration and yet I must agree with Misty J. Your exceptionally well written opinion is obviously the result of not only your workload but the effort and energy you put into that work. I know that it must seem overwhelming now but when you are breezing through college and less dedicated students are struggling it will be partially because of the foundation that was set in these early years. You will obviously be a great success in whatever path you choose in life. We are expecting great things from you young man!

Reply

IX Mendoza

10:10 pm on Sunday, April 21, 2013

CLD, nonsense. Similarly to Lance, I was extremely articulate as a young man. My guess is, more than likely, Lance has parents who never spoke to him like he was incapable of understanding advanced/abstract ideas and language. He also probably has had conversational relationships with older persons and likely reads a great deal. None of these things has anything to do with homework. A child of such advanced skill has probably been beyond his assigned homework since he began school.

Reply

Leave a comment