patching...
Update: For more local news about the community, follow Fox Point-Bayside Patch on Facebook »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

POLL: Are you Mac or PC?

The imminent release of competing operating systems — Windows 8 and Macintosh Mountain Lion — brings the question to the forefront again.

 

For all the tablets, smart phones, touch screens and other technological marvels that infiltrate our daily lives, personal computing still comes down to one simple question:

Are you Mac … or PC?

Apple and Microsoft remain the industry titans, and each has upgrades to its main operating system on the brink of release. Windows 8 is slated for debut this fall, Microsoft recently announced. Meanwhile, Apple just this week launched Mountain Lion, the $20 upgrade to its own operating system.

But the question has moved beyond a person’s preferred navigation of technology and now lives firmly in our popular culture. A series of Apple-produced TVs ads, co-starring Justin Long, started it. Microsoft responded with its own spots, proudly proclaiming, “I’m a PC.” The Pantsless Knights turned the question into a rap song and video, while the Onion delights in skewering the Macintosh culture.

So what about you? Are you Mac … or PC? (Full disclosure: Patchers use Macs on the job.) Vote in our poll and tell us in the comments.

  • Are you Mac or PC?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Mac
        66 (51%)
    • PC
        62 (48%)
    Total votes: 128
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Apple, Macintosh Mountain Lion, Microsoft, Patch Poll, and Windows 8

Scott L

6:33 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Definitely PC!
As a web designer and internet marketing consultant I need versatile and reliable operating systems that are also affordable. Macintosh is expensive and there are many, many compatibility issues that thwart any change to a Mac in the immediate future. I currently implement 5 PC towers (2 are back-ups), and I have 2 laptops to meet mobility demands.
With the exception of 1 laptop and PC that run Windows 7, all of my PC's run on Windows XP, which I personally find to be the most reliable, stable, and user friendly OS developed by Windows. It is rather unfortunate that support and security updates for Windows XP will end in April of 2014, and it is unfortunate that I will be forced to take those systems offline to eliminate security breaches.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Nicki

8:25 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I, too, have Windows XP and have found it just as you say. It is a shame that it will no longer be supported in 2014, but I suppose I will find that I can convert documents sent by others with Windows 7 more efficiently.

Nuitari

7:10 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I have always been pro-PC. As far as I could tell, they make the world go round. I don't see Macs being used in factories or on the stock exchange. Now, I also have an iPhone, so I am no longer anti-Apple, but I still think Macs will never steal the market. As a whole, Apple has peaked, with Android phones and tablets closing in.

Reply

Bob McBride

7:13 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

For my personal use, once Apple decided they were going to update their OS without requiring me to invest in new hardware every time they did (Mountain Lion being the exception for me at this point) AND they made it possible for me (via Bootcamp) to dual boot into Windows if I so chose, I made the switch. I've actually saved money since I have. I was an inveterate tinkerer who was constantly upgrading my hardware component by component. I've had the same computer for 6 years now. Never when I was strictly in the PC world did I hang onto anything that long.

Work is a different story as most of the industry specific applications are Windows based, including most of the structural design packages. Graphics is a mixed bag, with some departments preferring one platform over the other. Generally the older graphics folks who were brought up on Macs stick with them, so if they're running the department that's generally what you'll find exclusively. Younger generation seems to be more able to deal with both platforms, although I still see a preference for Macs.

I think we've yet to see the full potential of tablets. I can put my 10" Android tablet in its docking/charging station, connect my bluetooth KB and trackpad to it and it becomes a pretty good laptop substitute. I just got a Nexus 7 and they're working the bugs out of that platform pretty quickly. Windows better get on the stick in the tablet arena...pretty soon.

Reply

Chenzo

7:56 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Did everyone here drink the PC koolaid? If any other industry turned out such a crappy product, they would go under immediately. They crash, suseptible to viruses, and have there own comparability issues. Apple does turn out an expensive product, but it's worth it. I've run 2 iMacs without so much as a glitch. HD is solid, no viruses here. In fact I'm writing this on my iPod touch. I disagree that apple has peaked, it only continues to improve and a couple of months ago they over took PC sales, and continue to gain popularity.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tosa Mom

12:50 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Funny, the results say Mac, but the PC owners must see more need to explain their answer ;-)

N. Peske

8:11 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

My Mac is invaluable to me and worth every penny. My business relies on having a functioning machine, free of adware, spyware, viruses, and the like. The Mac Genius Bar experts can be accessed quickly (we've got a Genius Bar in Bayshore) and when I have a problem, I often can get it solved within an hour or less with a quick trick up to Bayshore.
I'm with Chenzo. You couldn't pay me enough to go back to PC. You pay for quality and service.

Reply

Bob McBride

8:21 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I hope the Mac users who cite as one of the reasons for using a Mac being free from various forms of malware are utilizing some form of protection along the lines of MacKeeper. You'd be surprised what can end up (and possibly already is) on your system.

Reply

DJ

8:30 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Had a pc for 10 years, switched to Mac. Now I've had my Mac for 4 years and I LOVE my Mac! Way too many issues with pc. Zero with Mac. Its hard to believe people still buy pcs. Kudos to Apple for being at the top of their game!

Reply

Denise Konkol

8:52 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I've been using both for about 2 years now, and they each have their strengths. PCs are more compatible yes, but it makes them more vulnerable to things you don't want, like viruses and malware. My Mac is great for working with photos, especially screen shots, but I'm a bit lost when I need to use Word because it seems to be missing the toolbars I need. However, it's likely I'll be buying a Mac, because they offer inexpensive in-person support to help you understand how to use the programs.

Reply
Comment_arrow

N. Peske

10:25 am on Monday, July 30, 2012

Denise, I work in Word on Mac all the time. It's very easy to change your toolbars. That said, Word for Office 2008 will crash constantly if you're in a big file with lots of track changes unless you know a few tricks. Go to View: Toolbars to change your toolbars.

Mike in Tosa

9:26 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

The gamer in me says PC due to a majority of games being for that platform. The IT guy in me says Mac mainly due to the flat-out stability of OSX. However, the Network Engineer in me says, either one - as long as I have access to a shell box or VM.

Reply

Daniel S.

10:49 am on Sunday, July 29, 2012

The divide between Mac & PC is similar to all divisions that take place in life. Everyone has their preference and for their own reason(s). Choice is the greatest thing we have, let's keep it that way.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Heather Asiyanbi

12:10 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

We're nearly an all-Mac family and I suspect in the next year or so we will be complete. I'll never go back to a PC if I can help it.

Reply

Nancy K

12:15 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

PC because I can't affored a Mac. And I had all sorts of issues with Windows XP that have virtually disappeared with Windows 7 which is so easy to use.

Reply

James R Hoffa

1:06 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Hoffa's sporting old school UNIX on his badass Commodore 64!

J/K - Hoffa is a custom built PC guy running Windows XP Pro SP3.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Heather Asiyanbi

9:07 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

@Hoffa - how is it that I have no trouble picturing you with that dinosaur Commodore?! ;)

Nancy K

2:30 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I have found that Mac owners tend to be very snobby...treating those who don't have one as though they were idiots. I'm just fine with my PC. Personal choice is a wonderful thing!

Reply

Mike B

2:39 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

BUt how many Mac people are running Windows on their Macs? hmm. I can buy 3 or 4 smoking hot PCs for the same price as one Mac. Limited software availability, proprietary hardware, hamstrung upgrade abilities, etc are the reason I will never look at a Mac. And Windows 7 runs on pretty much anything. I have 5-7 year old PCs running WIn7 just fine. Anyone who hasn't used Windows 7 really shouldn't comment on Windows as as OS. XP is/was great as it's still used by millions today. Vista was/is garbage. Anyone using it needs to stop. Windows 7 is great as it was the fastest selling OS in history.

Mac people love their Mac because they seem want them because they are some sort of status symbol. I use Windows because I just want a PC that does everything I need it to do at the price I want to spend.

Reply
Comment_arrow

M C

9:59 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Some pretty old arguments about Macs. You get what you pay for. Macs aren't the cheapest if you look only at initial cost. But given overall cost over the life of the computer Macs are competitive or even cheaper. They last longer, require less support and have less issues and therefore less downtime. And beyond that, the user experience on a Mac OS is, at least for many, a very different and better experience. I use a Mac because I can't stand sitting in front of Windows. The Mac OS and hardware is such a better experience in my opinion. The OS is rock solid, the interface is excellent and intuitive. It excels in ease of use. It is aesthetically pleasing to me as well. I'll pay the extra for that experience any day. Windows has closed the gap somewhat in recent years, but that is outweighed by the explosion of PC viruses, some of which are very damaging, that make PCs such a hassle today.

There are some situations where Windows is still a requirement, especially in proprietary business systems and financial/accounting, but for most everything else and certainly for anything creative, Mac is the way to go IMHO.

As to status symbols, I could care less.

Comment_arrow

N. Peske

10:37 am on Monday, July 30, 2012

Couldn't care less what's "cool." I just want 100 percent reliability. I don't care about selection of software, either. I only use about 7 programs. I think the choice really depends on one's needs. I can't fathom a business owner using a PC if they have a choice. It's just too dicey.
I got my Mac when a virus totally screwed me up on a severe deadline. My client said, "If my book hits the bestseller list, I'll buy you any computer you like." And she did...that's how I switched to Mac. NEVER AGAIN!

Sunrocket

3:18 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

One 6 year old laptop pc and 3 year old desk top pc - both have windows xp. Love them both, never have any problems, have malware and anti virus programs. Have never crashed. Works for me.

Reply

Kevin Byrum

5:46 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Mac. Have converted most of my friends to Mac through the years and they wish I had got them to switch sooner . It's nice to have a product that works so well. No viruses, no worms, or malware. Apple just does things right!

Reply

Nancy K

6:06 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I've had PCs for 16 years. Have never had a virus that anti-virus software didn't catch and get rid of. Have had one HD die in a Netbook, but that was due to misuse. Mac owners are under the misconception that they can't get viruses/worms/malware. My daughter thought that too.

Reply

JayZee

7:16 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

About five years ago I had one of those days. Crashes, lockups, reboots and so forth and I said to myself, self why do you put up with all this and now you have to update all three PCs with current anti-virus software. So I marched down to Mayfair and got a low priced MacBook. HOLY COW, everything works, most settings are intuitive and easy to learn. I soon passed that to my wife and got a MacBook Pro, my son picked up another Macbook to use in college. All my mobile devices work seamlessly and the compact aluminum chassis is totally awesome. Apple keeps coming up with new features like iCloud that just keeps the fun going. MS has Office for Mac, my GPS maker has Mac software. And yes I have Windoze XP in Parallel for those unfortunate instances when I have to program my scanners or 2-way radios. Once you go Mac, you never go back.

Reply

Dave Bruno

7:33 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Mac for computer idiots like me. Amazing what it can do and so simple.

Reply

Abe Van Dyke

8:11 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I see so my judgement here people and it's kinda silly. Example: "Mac owners are snobby". What you need to do is realize both operating systems have their place. Windows XP, soon to be 3versions old is championed because it is stable... But how many years ago was it released and needed fixes along the way. Apple on the other hand is moving in a different direction with Mountain Lion; one of the major things will be Facebook integration in Fall. Look it up. I personally don't need the ability to Like, Share and Rate everyerything; all the time. Windows has many businesses that invested time on their system back when Apple was still in its infancy and ya know what, if you spent that time and money... The business will probably keep it and upgrade as needed. Apple has long been the standard for graphic arts industry businesses from photos, design, video, etc. Both companies have their own word processor... Yet Word, a Mircrosoft application is far favored over Apples Pages. I would be willing to bet that well over 60% of Macs have Word on them. Apple has made it so you can virtually install Windows which is a plus. Viruses and all that; both systems get them... But Windows computers are more likely to be hit; for now. We have a generation of kids being brought up Macs, so one day the tides may turn and Macs have widely advertised virus issues. One moment please... ~A

Reply

Abe Van Dyke

8:12 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

... And I'm back. Going on... Price: you get what you pay for end of story. For some a $200 desktop is enough and others need a $5,000 desktop; it's all about what you need the machine to do so quit whining. There's plenty more to say, but you get the idea. ~A

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Matthew Schroeder

8:38 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I'm sure there are downsides to Macs compared to PCs, but as a longtime Mac user — in a household with a PC user who tends to curse her computer a lot — I'm not seeing them.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Johnny Paycheck

9:47 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

The downside of the Mac is that replacement parts for it cost 400-1000% more than the same part for a PC.

Daniel S.

8:48 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

"I have found that Mac owners tend to be very snobby...treating those who don't have one as though they were idiots." I wonder, are iPhone users snobs, how about iPad, iPod? My experience tells me a few things about why many people I have known since the early 90's chose PC's. They were cheaper (in many ways), more knew how to fix them (they needed it), they ran games and comparable graphics cards didn't exist for the Mac.. The Mac has always been easier to set-up & was typically less buggy overall. They were expensive and are compared to some of the disposable PC's out there. My 22 year old Mac still works fine, but is beyond upgrade, as is my 15 year old Mac. My 9 year old Mac was made obsolete by introduction of Intel boards in the Mac world. I have a brother who was a dedicated PC user for 20 years. He bought an iMac 2 years ago and immediately said: I can't believe how easy it is to set up! He cannot believe he didn't change sooner. I have friends that said Apple was going under, for years. Granted, if not for the iPod, they might have. They are gaining ground in the computer world since the introduction of the iPad, it's making people rethink their personal computer choice. Some Mac people might think they are immune to viruses, etc., but many of us know we are not immune, it's just that those looking to create havoc within operating systems, seek to cause trouble for as large a group as possible; that being the PC market. More isn't always better : (

Reply
Comment_arrow

Johnny Paycheck

11:11 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Steve Jobs made Apple what it was-- he did it the first time, and then when he left the company they lost almost all of their market share and would have gone out of business had he not returned and started doing things his way again. The man has been dead for less than a year so it's too early to say at this point what will happen to the company with their creative genius gone for good. They have not invented anything new and innovative since he's been gone though and if the past is any indication of the future the company will be in trouble again within 3-5 years.

Steve Rogers

8:58 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

I'm a PC working and saving so that I can become a Mac

Reply

C. Sanders

9:25 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

iMac, iPhone and iPad at home with an XP PC at he office.

Reply

AWD

9:26 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

All of the Mac people I've met are arrogant elitist zealots.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Dirk Gutzmiller

9:47 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

AWD - Not at all in my experience....most MAC users tend to be Democrats, not the arrogant and elitist bankers, hedge fund operators, Wall Streeters, etc.

Comment_arrow

Nancy K

10:24 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Dirk says: .most MAC users tend to be Democrats, not the arrogant and elitist bankers, hedge fund operators, Wall Streeters, etc.

Ah, you mean most MAC users tend to be Democrats who expect the government to give them one because they are entitled to have one, paid for by the people who use PCs. :-)

Comment_arrow

M C

10:41 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Seems like you haven't met many Mac people.

Johnny Paycheck

10:00 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Mac's are nice... until they break and you find out that Apple gets $400 for a power supply and $800 for an LCD screen, and that's IF you can do your own repairs-- otherwise add another 30-50% for labor. I got quoted $1000 once on a 13" LCD screen replacement on a Macbook Air. You can buy a 55" flatscreen TV for less than that so I promptly deposited the machine the trash, which fortunately was still free at the time. Generally speaking it's more economical to repair a Cadillac than a Macbook computer.

Also almost none of the computer skills that you pick up while using a mac will ever convert into computer knowledge that you can use at your job. Aside from printing companies and graphics design jobs I can think of no business that has their employees working on Macs. They're just too expensive and won't run much of the software that businesses run on.

Reply

Nick Poulos

10:04 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Mac's are the best designed, most inclusive machines on the market. As to running programs for your business: even custom-designed, "internally-focused", software can run smoothly on your Mac. Unlike an earlier comment: I discarded 8 PC's for 7 Macs; and never have I been unhappy with that decision. Sorry: no other machines hold a candle to what Cupertino produces.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bob McBride

10:33 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

As to running programs for your business: even custom-designed, "internally-focused", software can run smoothly on your Mac.

**************

Incorrect. There's plenty of custom designed "internally focused" business related programs built for the PC platform that won't run on a Mac.

Why even make such a ridiculous statement? Frankly, in a business environment, whether you're networking a couple dozen or a couple hundred computers, why would you want to do it with a bunch of Macs when you can accomplish exactly the same thing on PCs for a lot less - even if that was a realistic option?

Comment_arrow

Johnny Paycheck

10:53 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

" even custom-designed, "internally-focused", software can run smoothly on your Mac."

Sure it can, albeit not so smoothly, and provided you run the Mac's "parallels" Windows emulator, in which case you still have to install a version of windows, an antivirus program, etc. In that case what you have is a really expensive piece of hardware that's trying to pretend it's a PC and two operating systems to maintain instead of one. You will also have a much more limited pool of potential employees to choose from provided they need to know how to operate the machine, or else you will have to fund a much higher learning curve as your employees learn to do everything a computer all over again.

Comment_arrow

M C

1:23 am on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

You don't have to run an "emulator." Macs have been Intel processor based for years. Windows on a Mac is not running in emulation; it is running on Intel with only slight mods for connectivity, etc. Years ago with PowerPCs Windows could be installed but ran in emulation with an additional layer of software that emulated an Intel chip for Windows to work with the PowerPC processor of the Mac. This made Windows run slow, with a variety of other issues. This is no longer the case with Macs of the past five years.

Daniel S.

11:36 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

It's really sad that so many people still don't seem to understand that the Mac is an extremely capable computer, capable of doing things efficiently, quickly and across multiple platforms. It is extremely easy to learn rarely needs repairs. In 22 years, I've had to replace a battery once and could've replaced a mother board for $400, but seeing as it was old Motorola tech and was no longer upgradable, I chose to buy a new Mac after 10 years of use with near ZERO investment during that period. I spent 70$ for a disk utility cleaning program after 7 years. FYI, many people in the scientific & research communities including NASA have been using Macs for roughly 10 years. I've been to stores that have iMac registers, the list goes on and on.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Johnny Paycheck

11:44 pm on Sunday, July 29, 2012

Sure they're great in some areas, but one has to ask why it's never occurred to any fortune 500 company CEO to replace all of their Windows machine's with Mac's... Or perhaps it has and they've found that the total cost of ownership is too high and it doesn't do much of what they would need to accomplish with it?

Andrew Benson

1:57 am on Monday, July 30, 2012

When working in Graphic Design or Digital Media, it's assumed that Mac is the way to go. Not the case, On the highest end desktop Macintosh, it took me more than 9 hours to render a 52 second animation, and even then it ended up resulting in a fatal error. The same day I wen home and installed the After Effects trial on my custom built PC.
It took under 4 hours to render the video, and properly convert it. The most hilarious thing about this. My PC costs a quarter of what the Mac costs.

Reply
Comment_arrow

M C

1:32 am on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Overall Mac is definitely the way to go for graphic design, etc. There may be some particular tasks that run faster on a PC, but the bulk of the creative world is on Mac. And even in animation your above comparison is not likely a representative comparison of Macs and PCs. It would depend on what animation software was being used, which Macs and PCs were being compared, and precisely which tasks were being attempted.
The reality is that most folks also don't want to deal with your cheap, "custom-built" PC and all the issues and technical skills needed to build it. People have been building cheap PCs for decades now, even in their garages. The mishmash of parts may be cheaper, but the user experience, lifespan, and resale does not compare with Macs, or even with better quality PCs.
The key advantage Macs have, IMHO, is the clean and tight integration of software and hardware to create a great and intuitive user experience. I don't care how cheap or fast your PC is, it can't duplicate that aspect of Mac computing. It is probably the biggest reason why I sit in front of a Mac every day instead of a PC, and why I would happily pay more for it.

Bren

6:19 pm on Monday, July 30, 2012

I own a desktop pc, newer laptop pc (6 months), and MacBook Pro (in addition to an iPhone). All solid equipment, each of which are used for different purposes. I also like being able to hook the laptops to the tv via HDMI cables.

Reply

JO

3:48 pm on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Here is a good article to read for people who believe that Apple is not vulnerable to security breaches: http://www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2012/08/apple-amazon-mat-honan-hacking/all/.

Reply
Comment_arrow

M C

1:43 am on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Macs are not invulnerable to viruses. Any OS is subject to security breaches, but the reality is that in the current computing environment PCs are much more susceptible than Macs, due both to the number of viruses and worms, etc., on the PC platform, the potential seriousness of their impact, and the level of security Macs provide with their Unix-based OS over PCs with Windows.

If you read the above article, you should also note that
a. the hackers did not really break into the Mac operating system. Instead they managed to get a hold of passwords that gave them access to areas by which they could make trouble. This is a breakdown of a person's individual security habits, and a breach of Amazon and Apple's customer service, etc., not a breakdown of the OS.
b. no viruses were even involved. And the entire incident would have been avoided if the user had been smarter about use of passwords, linked accounts, backing up data, etc.

Leave a comment